Freddie Mac heads into its third-quarter report with a striking disconnect. On its last call, management described a business firing on more cylinders than at any point in the past year: net income of $3.8 billion, up 61% from a year earlier, net worth climbing to $78 billion and guarantee fees still edging higher. The stock has since fallen nearly 29% while the S&P 500 gained 4%. The October 29 release, due before the open, needs to show whether that growth rests on durable operating gains or on optimistic home-price assumptions.
The usual scorecard is of limited use here. Consensus calls for earnings per share of zero, matching both the prior quarter and the year-ago period. Common shareholders have not been capturing the company's profits, so the figures that matter are net income, the pace of net worth accumulation and the shrinking capital deficit. Revenue comparisons are distorted too. The $6.32 billion consensus implies growth of almost 19,000% from the year-ago figure and sits well below the $34.26 billion recorded last quarter, which points to inconsistent reporting bases rather than any real swing in the business. Management offered no formal guidance, so the benchmark is the trajectory the company itself has set. Quarterly net income has gone from $2.8 billion to $3.6 billion to $3.8 billion, and net worth has risen by roughly $3 billion to $4 billion each quarter. Another step up in both would keep the story intact.
The central question is the quality of those earnings. Much of last quarter's strength came from an $846 million single-family credit benefit, driven by a house-price forecast that was raised well above the December baseline. That forecast was already lower than the one used in the first quarter, and single-family reserve coverage fell to 19 basis points from 22. A business can release reserves for good fundamental reasons, but here the underlying credit picture was not improving. Serious delinquencies held at 60 basis points, up 5 from a year earlier, with 2022-and-later vintages under pressure, and charge-offs ran well ahead of last year's pace. If home-price assumptions are trimmed again, that tailwind could shrink or reverse, and headline income could stall even if the core franchise is healthy.
Multifamily is the other key test. The segment's net income nearly doubled year over year, new business jumped 58% to $18 billion, and the shift toward fully guaranteed securitizations lifted net interest income by 40%. Delinquencies, however, rose to 51 basis points from 43, which management attributed to elevated rates and stress among small-balance loans. Steady or rising volumes alongside a stabilizing delinquency rate would support the inflection story. Another jump would suggest the segment's growth is coming with more risk attached. Volume is also worth checking on the single-family side. Refinance activity fell to 33% of purchases from a four-year high of 42% as mortgage rates drifted up, so origination momentum may have cooled.
Sentiment has soured sharply. Bearish readings have climbed to roughly 38% from about 7% ahead of the last report. At $3.93, the stock trades far below its 200-day moving average of $5.92 and sits in the lower half of a post-earnings range that ran from $2.70 to $5.82. That range lies entirely below the prior quarter's $5.00 to $7.98 band, a clear sign the market has re-rated the shares lower regardless of the reported results. A sharply negative mood can lower the bar for a relief move, but it does not guarantee one.
The narrative holds if Freddie Mac grows net worth again while showing credit stabilizing in both segments, with less dependence on forecast-driven reserve releases. Updates on the VantageScore 4.0 rollout and AI-driven efficiency would be welcome but secondary. What matters most is whether the company can still produce strong earnings if home prices stop doing the heavy lifting.