SNEX StoneX Group Inc.

NASDAQ
$39.45

StoneX Misses as Institutional and Retail Weakness Overshadow Commercial Strength and RJO Synergy Wins

StoneX Group closed a record fiscal year with a quarter that fell well short of expectations. Fiscal fourth-quarter diluted EPS of $0.66 missed the $0.86 consensus by 23.3%, and Earnings Whispers shows earnings down 36.9% year over year. The company's own split-adjusted comparison is gentler. After two three-for-two stock splits in 2026, the release shows diluted EPS down 6% from $0.70, with net income down 2% to $84.2 million. Either way, earnings fell year over year. Fiscal 2026 was a banner year: net income rose 72% to $525.4 million, annual ROE was 19.5%, and EPS reached $4.15. But that annual record obscures a sharp fade through the year. Quarterly net income fell from $174.3 million in Q2 to $127.9 million in Q3 and $84.2 million in Q4. Quarterly ROE slid from 26.5% to 18.4% to 11.6%. That deceleration is the central tension.

The revenue headline needs context. Reported revenue of $37.46 billion grew 14.5% and appears to beat the $1.38 billion consensus by an enormous 2,614.5%. That comparison is driven by gross physical commodity sales of $36.1 billion, which flow almost entirely through cost of sales. The more relevant measures were operating revenues of $1.46 billion, up 21%, and net operating revenues of $655.2 million, up 12%. Net operating revenues also fell 9% sequentially. The RJO acquisition contributed $195.8 million of operating revenue versus $141.0 million a year ago, so part of the year-over-year growth reflects a full quarter of the deal rather than two months. Pre-tax income rose 10% to $119.6 million. However, tax expense jumped 51%, so net income declined. Earnings quality was also mixed in both directions:

  • A $17.9 million unrealized mark-to-market loss on Treasury and Agency holdings depressed interest income, against a $9.0 million gain a year earlier.
  • A $7.1 million net bad-debt recovery flattered expenses.

Beneath the consolidated figures, the segments diverged sharply. Commercial was the standout:

  • Net operating revenue rose 54% to $334 million, and segment income rose 66% to $188 million.
  • Segment margin expanded to 56% from 52%.
  • Physical contracts net revenue doubled to $100 million, led by precious metals.
  • OTC derivatives net revenue rose 87% as contract volume nearly doubled.

Payments also improved. Average daily volume hit a record $101 million (+28%) and net revenue rose 18%, though rate per million slipped 9%. Institutional and retail are where the quarter broke down:

  • Institutional net operating revenue fell 13% year over year and 18% sequentially, and segment income dropped 25%.
  • Securities rate per million fell 23% on narrower spreads, and securities net revenue dropped 32% quarter over quarter.
  • Prime services net revenue fell 27%, and net interest and fees on client balances fell 16%.
  • Self-Directed/Retail segment income collapsed 56% as FX/CFD volume fell 17%. Management described a 'perfect storm' of low volatility, with the VIX near 16.

Management's tone shifted noticeably from the enthusiasm of the first half. Executives leaned on the diversified model and the point that markets 'do not move in a straight line.' They characterized the institutional softness as transitory and said activity was recovering in the December quarter. That is a management expectation, not a reported result.

The most tangible positives came from execution on the RJO deal, where the company raised its synergy figures:

  • Integration finished on schedule.
  • The expense synergy exit run rate reached $55 million, versus the $50 million original target and roughly $45-46 million guided last quarter. Another $10 million is expected in fiscal 2027.
  • Capital synergies reached $70 million against a $50 million target, with $13 million more expected in Q1.
  • The interest-rate swap book grew to $2.7 billion at a 3.57% average rate.

Management also pointed to its AI and digital platform push, retail re-platforming, and new payments onboarding through XPAY. On the cautionary side, client float fell 4% sequentially, and net income sensitivity to a 100-basis-point rate move eased to $42.3 million from $46.9 million. Bears have legitimate ammunition: the businesses that drove first-half upside depend on spreads, volatility and rates, and all three are moving against StoneX.

The market had already been pricing in that fade. Shares fell 19.9% from the $67.24 open after the August report to $53.83. They sit 23.8% below the 200-day moving average of $70.69. The Earnings Whispers price and AVWAP trend readings remain negative. Investor sentiment, already slightly negative, weakened modestly from -0.12 to -0.20. That is a meaningful but not dramatic deterioration, suggesting expectations were subdued before the miss.

The bottom line is that StoneX delivered a record year but exited it with clearly decelerating quarterly earnings, a sizable EPS miss and a sharp ROE decline. Commercial strength, payments growth and better-than-promised RJO synergies keep the structural story intact. The near-term debate now hinges on whether management is right that the institutional and retail weakness is cyclical and already reversing.

← Back to SNEX news

Read our preview of this report →