AXP American Express Company

NYSE
$325.17

American Express Company Q3 F2026 Earnings Call Transcript

AI Conference Call Analysis

Sign in or subscribe to read.
Operator
Conference Call Operator
Welcome to the American Express Q3 2026 Earnings Call.
Donna
Operator
At this time, all participants are on a listen-only mode until we conduct a question and answer session later on. As a reminder, today's call is being recorded. I will now turn the call over to Kartik Ramachandran, Head of Investor Relations.
Kartik Ramachandran
Head of Investor Relations
Thank you, Donna, and thank you all for joining today's call. Today's question contains forward-looking details about the companies' future business and financial performance. These are based on management current expectations and are subject to risks and uncertainties. Factors that could cause actual results or differ materially from the statements are included in today's presentation slides and in our report on file with the SEC. Today's discussion also contains non-GAAP financial measures. Comparable GAAP financial measures are included in this quarter's earnings materials as well as the prior period earnings materials discussed today. All of these are posted on our website at ir.americanexpress.com. We'll begin today with Steve Squeri, Chairman and CEO, followed by Christophe Le Caillec, Chief Financial Officer. After their remarks, we'll move to Q&A. With that, I'll turn it over to Steve.
Steve Squeri
Chairman and CEO
Thank you, Kartik. Good morning and thanks for joining us. We had another strong quarter with record revenues of $20 billion of 9% and EPS of $5.42 reported. and $4.68 on an adjusted basis. Given our strong performance year to date, we are reaffirming our revenue growth guidance of 10% and raising our EPS guidance to between 1830 and 1860 on a reported basis or between 1760 and 1790 on an adjusted basis. There are a number of discrete items in this quarter's results. Christophe will go through them in detail. I'll highlight a few of them. First, with the closing of the global business travel transaction in the quarter, We're dropping two-thirds of the gain to the bottom line. Excluding the impact of the gain as well as the portion of it we're using for restructuring, adjusted EPS was $4.68. Second, adjusted EPS includes an expense for legal matters, which includes the unreserved portion of the recently announced civil money penalty levied by the OCC. The fine does not impact our full year 2026 guidance. The orders do not impose an asset cap on the company. and the costs associated with remediation are not anticipated to affect 2027 guidance. More importantly, the deficiency cited in the consent order should not have occurred and we are accountable for addressing them thoroughly. This is critical to our future and to maintaining the trust that our customers, regulators, colleagues and investors place in us. We've earned that trust over many years and we can never take it for granted. Also this quarter, as I mentioned, we're using a portion of the gain from the Global Business Travel Transaction to continue positioning the company for long-term growth. Our strong business performance throughout the year has enabled us to step up our marketing and technology investments, so we decided to use some of the gain to invest and make the organization more efficient and better prepared for the future. As a result, we took a $336 million charge for restructuring in the quarter, which is expected to result in the elimination of approximately 5% of our positions globally. Because this quarter's charge is somewhat larger than what we typically do, I'll take a moment to provide a bit more context. We've got good momentum, but to accelerate innovation and win over the next few years, we needed to become a more agile and efficient organization. With that objective in mind, earlier this year I asked the senior leadership team to identify ways to streamline their organizations, align their teams on the most critical deliverables, and reduce layers to speed decision-making. When completed, we believe this exercise will help us operate and execute more effectively and give us greater capacity to invest in our business priorities. I'd also like to highlight the latest example of how we're continuing to invest in our membership model to enhance its value to our card members. Yesterday's announcement of our exclusive partnership with Airbnb, which follows the recent announcements of new and expanded Centurion lounges and our next generation corporate card expense management program. We know that card members enjoy the exceptional variety and scope of Airbnb's network of unique locations, and we're excited to bring over 1 million listings globally into our AddX Travel program, as well as expanding travel benefits for eligible U.S. card members. Next, I'd like to talk about how we're thinking about AI and the rise of AI assistance. There's been a lot of talk about how companies are using AI to increase productivity, automate processes, and generally make their organizations more efficient. We're using AI to do all of those things too. But I want to talk about AI and agentic commerce from the customer's perspective, how their experience will evolve, and what it means for American Express. It's still early in the game. Agentic transaction volumes are still small, but the direction is clear. AI is fundamentally changing how consumers and businesses discover, compare, decide, pay, and manage their finances and their lives. But while AI agents are able to act on customers' behalf, that doesn't change who the customer is. Our customer remains the card member, and the job remains the same. Deliver differentiated value and have their back. The way I think about AI is simple. AI gives us the opportunity to make Amex membership even more valuable. We are well positioned to do just that. Our differentiated assets, closed-loop network, first-party data, and brand built on trust, security, and service are even greater advantages in an AI world. Our goal is to have membership travel with our card members throughout these new AI-powered experiences, shaping recommendations, securing payments, activating the right value, and supporting the customer after. In other words, we want to become even more essential to our customers. Continuing to embed Amex membership where decisions happen. That's the key idea between the five key areas we're using AI to enhance the customer experience. First, value propositions. Amex membership is all encompassing. It's a combination of the unique access, benefits, experiences, rewards, convenience, world-class partnerships, and great service we offer our card members. AI gives us the opportunity to take our value propositions much further. combining the proprietary insights from our closed loop, our partner relationships, and access to membership experiences to create entirely new forms of value that are more personalized and differentiated than ever before. Take dining. Through Rezzy and our restaurant partnerships, we are already giving eligible card members access to sought-after restaurants and exclusive experiences. We're now using AI to combine that ecosystem with our understanding of individual card members' tastes and preferences. Our dining companion, for example, uses insights from card members' spending to make personalized restaurant recommendations. Looking ahead, we can imagine using AI to better understand the kinds of experiences different card members would enjoy and then working with our restaurant partners to create distinctive experiences tailored to those interests at a level of personalization scale we couldn't achieve before. That's the opportunity, taking something American Express already does exceptionally well and leveraging cutting edge technology to make it even more personal, relevant, and differentiated. Second, customer acquisition. As AI changes how customers search and choose financial products, our ambition is to help shape the discovery and decision making process, ensuring that the full value of American Express membership is clear and compelling wherever prospective customers are exploring options. We're evolving how we reach prospective customers in this new environment, rethinking traditional search and digital channels, optimizing how our products and benefits are discovered and represented by AI platforms, and developing new ways to reach customers through LLMs and agents. At the same time, we're transforming our marketing and acquisition engine. By combining AI and our proprietary data, we can better identify the right prospects, match them with relevant products and offers and create more personalized shopping, product application, and onboarding experiences. Our goal is to make becoming an American Express member increasingly seamless and tailored to the individual, helping us attract more high-quality customers, improve conversion, and make every marketing dollar work harder. Third, engagement. AI gives us the opportunity to fundamentally change how card members experience membership, making it more proactive, personalized, and relevant throughout their lives. While we'll do this within our own channels and through partnering with leading AI companies to make our membership assets available through their platforms customers use to discover, plan, and make decisions. Let me give you a few examples. We're deepening our partnership with OpenAI to continue bringing Amex card membership into ChatGPT. Earlier this year, we launched Resi Restaurant Discovery Reservations in ChatGPT and are working with OpenAI to launch an Amex plugin that will enable card members to discover and enroll in Amex offers. We continue to collaborate closely on the future of payments and have built proprietary dining and hotel conversational experiences that use OpenAI models. In our own channels, Wishlist, Builder, and our travel app, uses AI to help customers discover hotels and plan trips. And through our partnership with Perplexity, eligible business card members can now access Amex-curated AI tools for tasks like cash flow forecasting and creating marketing campaigns. Our vision is for Amex membership to become an intelligent, personalized experience, proactively bringing the right experiences and benefits to card members at the right moment wherever their journey begins. Fourth, payments. As AI agents begin to transact on behalf of customers, trust and security become even more important. Our ambition is to make American Express the trusted way to pay across AI ecosystems, ensuring that card members remain in control and that the protections and differentiated value they expect from us extend into this new way to pay. Right now, we're helping to shape the standards for trusted agentic payments. The principle is straightforward. We need to know who the agent is, what the customer has authorized it to do, and have a secure way to complete the payment. The transaction of the future will carry more than a payment credential. It will carry context. We outlined the capabilities we're building in our Agentic Commerce Experiences, or ACE, developer kit we published in the second quarter. And we're working with several leading AI companies on integrating ACE into their platforms to enable agent powered transactions. Earlier this month, we also released our intent intelligence framework that sets forth a standard to help ensure customer purchase intent is authenticated and preserved. And we're developing agent purchase protection to extend the backing of American Express to eligible purchases when registered agents share intent data and then make mistakes. As both a network and an issuer, we're uniquely positioned to connect the card member, the agent, and the merchant throughout the transaction journey. Our near-term focus is on building these capabilities and integrating with leading partners. But the longer-term opportunity is much bigger, ensuring that whenever and however customers choose to transact, they can do so with confidence, control, and the membership value and backing they expect from American Express. And fifth, servicing. Service has always been a defining part of American Express membership. We intend to combine AI speed, personalization, and proactive capabilities with the empathy, expertise, and judgment of our colleagues so customers get faster, more seamless service when their needs are straightforward and exceptional personal support when it matters most. We've been deploying a broad suite of AI tools that help our colleagues access the right information, understand customer needs, develop personalized recommendations, and resolve issues more effectively. We're also expanding the use of AI to strengthen our capabilities in areas like complaints and disputes, to identify issues earlier, understand root causes, improve decision making, and resolve problems faster. And we recently launched our first few conversational AI voice agents. Looking ahead, we want to move beyond responding to requests to anticipating and resolving customers' needs end-to-end. That means delivering even more seamless service across channels, addressing issues before customers need to reach out, and using insights from every interaction to continually improve the customer experience. Ultimately, we see AI as a powerful accelerator of our long-term growth strategy. It gives us new opportunities to make membership more valuable Attract and engage more customers, drive more of their spend, and serve them more effectively. We're still in the early stages and will continue to invest with discipline, but we believe AI enables us to build on the competitive strengths we've developed over decades and drive sustainable, profitable growth for years to come. To wrap up, the company continues to perform well. We are fortunate to have a premium customer base, which continues to show great strength and stability. We have good momentum and our financial results continue to be strong. The progress we're making across the business, together with our talented colleagues who are focused on delivering the best customer experience every day, gives me great confidence in the future. We are on track to deliver another year of 10% revenue growth and mid-team DPS growth. And more importantly, we have momentum to sustain strong results in the years ahead. I'll now turn it over to Christophe.
Christophe Le Caillec
Chief Financial Officer
Thanks, Steve, and good morning, everyone. Q3 was another strong quarter, and we continue to see good momentum across the business. Customer behavior looked very similar to what we've seen over the past year. Strong and consistent spend growth, especially in the T&E categories, balanced growth in line with spend, high retention rates, and excellent credit performance. The strength and stability in customer behavior drove revenue up 9% year over year, with net car fee growth accelerating to 17% effects adjusted. This quarter reflected stable VCE engagement, discipline operating expenses, and continued investment in future growth. We reported gap EPS of $5.42 this quarter, up 31%. Before getting into the business trends, let me walk through EPS in more detail. There are several adjusted and notable items this quarter, and I want to be clear about their impact on our results. First, the sale of our investments in the Global Business Travel Group resulted in a gain of $1.11 per share. Second, as we previously said, we expected to use a portion of the gain to support the company's long-term growth and consistent with that objective, we have taken a restructuring charge of $0.37 per share. Adjusting for the global business travel group gain and the restructuring charge, EPS was $4.68, up 13% year-over-year. Adjusted EPS includes three other notable items this quarter. First, an increase in legal reserves of $0.51, which includes the remaining portion of the OCC civil money penalty that was not previously reserved for. as well as a reserve for the anticipated settlement of an unrelated matter. The second item is a discrete tax benefit of 29 cents per share. And finally, a 24 cents benefit from the most recent updates to the CECL reserve models. Combined, these three items had no meaningful impact on the adjusted EPS this quarter. Turning to build business. Overall spend was 8% this quarter, in line with the trend of the past four quarters. This quarter included about a 60 basis point year-over-year impact from the co-brand exits that I previously discussed, with the Amazon co-brand portfolio sale happening midway through the quarter. Sequentially, spend growth also saw a small impact from the last quarter's Amazon Prime Day and other promotional retail days in the U.S. These impacts were mostly concentrated in goods and services, which grew 7% this quarter. Discretionary spending was strong, with T&E up 10% year-over-year. Airline spending accelerated to 13%, while restaurants, our largest T&E category, saw spend growth of 9%. U.S. consumer spending was up 9.4% this quarter, reflecting the continued strength in our premium customer base. While growth moderated slightly through Q2, it was in line with Q1 and continues to run above the levels we saw in 2024 and 2025. In fact, Q3 is the third highest quarterly growth rate in three years. One year after the US consumer platinum refresh, spend retention remains at 99% for the portfolio. Turning to commercial, spend was up 3% this quarter, Excluding the impact of the core bank portfolio exits, spend growth was 5% for the second consecutive quarter. We're seeing strong take-up on the graphite card that we launched earlier this year. And looking ahead, our new corporate cashback card and integrated expense management capabilities will give us additional opportunities to drive engagement and spend growth. Spend growth in international was up 11%. Merchant coverage now reaches over 190 million locations globally, up from 160 million a year ago. Outside the US, the number of locations accepting annex has more than doubled over the last four years. We are pleased with the outcomes of our investments in customer acquisition and driving greater engagement from our existing card members. We require 3.1 million new cards in the quarter with 76% of new accounts on fee-paying products. Turning to balances and credit on page 10. Total balances increased 8% year-over-year in line with billed business. Importantly, we continue to grow balances from our premium customer base while maintaining best-in-class credit results. This is very much by design, reflecting our focus on attracting highly credit-worthy customers who both spend and borrow with us. and the quality of those customers is reflected not only in our credit performance but also in the economics of our lending business. In fact, this quarter is a good illustration of this dynamic. Balances grew 8%, NII grew at a faster rate at 10% and write-off dollars only grew at 3%. Delinquency rate remained very low and stable for the last 15 quarters The rate has been either 1.2 or 1.3%. Overall provision expense was $985 million, including a reserve release of $211 million. The reserve release was driven by enhancements to our CECL models. We feel very good about the quality of our credit performance and the stability we see in the portfolio. Turning now to revenue. Revenue was $20.1 billion, up 9% year over year. Revenue growth would have been about a one point higher excluding the impact of the small business core brand portfolio exits. Net interest income was up 10% this quarter, continuing to grow faster than balances. NII growth in the quarter at about a two percentage point impact year over year from the core brand portfolio exits. Net car fees continue to be at our fastest growing revenue line. As expected, we've seen an acceleration in growth 17% FX adjusted this quarter, supported by the very strong results we've seen on the US Platinum Refresh. Turning now to expenses. The VCE to revenue ratio was 44.3% this quarter. We are beginning to see growth in card member services moderate following the step up from the Platinum Refresh last year. Looking ahead, we expect VCE growth to moderate significantly in Q4 as we fully lock the Platinum Refresh, returning to growth rates more consistent with what we saw before the Refresh. We are also continuing to evolve our value propositions in ways that enhance the customer experience and support attractive product economics. For example, we recently introduced membership rewards redemption for statement balances which has seen strong adoption. This feature provides card members with greater flexibility in how they use their rewards while also supporting the overall economics of the program. Marketing expense was up 11%, reflecting the additional investments we made in customer acquisition following our strong performance in the first half of the year. On page 18, We can see operating expenses were down 3% year-over-year, reflecting the notable items I mentioned earlier. Excluding the Global Business Travel Group gain, restructuring and legal items, underlying OPEX growth was 3%. As Steve said earlier, we have invested significantly in strengthening risk and controls in the past few years, and we will do what's needed to establish a durable and effective program that meets our own and our regulators' expectations. The ongoing investments are in our run rate and we do not expect the additional costs to impact our 2027 guidance. Before closing, let me address one of the most recurring questions we get about our margins and how they have evolved over the past years, especially as we ramp up marketing and technology spend and invested in richer value propositions via the VCE expenses. The decisions we make are profitability-based and aim at maximizing risk-adjusted returns and capital generation. Page 19 shows our ROE over the last 16 years. As you can see, we have increased the ROE from an average of 25% to 28% 10 years ago to around 35% more recently. And over this period of time, we are on track to more than double the size of our revenue and triple EPS. At the same time, we have also reduced the share count by over a quarter. This performance can be tracked back to our spent and fee-based model, characterized by high loyalty and engagement, greater differentiation versus competitors, lower credit risk, including in distress, lower capital intensity, and higher operating leverage from scale. These results in very strong capital generation that we return to shareholders. In Q3 specifically, We returned $2.2 billion of capital to shareholders, including $1.6 billion of share repurchase and $0.6 billion of dividends. And we ended the quarter with a CET1 ratio of 10.9%, reflecting the gain from the sale of GBTG that happened at the end of the quarter. That brings me to guidance. Given our performance year-to-date, we are reaffirming our four-year revenue growth guidance of 10%, and raising EPS guidance to a range of 1830 to 1860 and 1760 to 1790 on an adjusted basis. With that, I'll turn the call back over to Kartik and we'll take your questions.
Kartik Ramachandran
Head of Investor Relations
Thank you, Christophe. We will now start the Q&A session. We ask that you please limit yourself to just one question. Thank you for your cooperation. Operator?
Donna
Operator
Ladies and gentlemen, if you wish to ask a question, please press star then one on your touchtone phone. You'll hear a tone indicating that you've been placed in queue. You may remove yourself from the queue at any time by pressing star, then two. If you're using a speakerphone, please pick up the handset before pressing the numbers. Our first question is coming from Sanjay Sakrani of KBW. Please go ahead.
Steve Squeri
Chairman and CEO
Thank you. Good morning. Steve, definitely appreciated all your comments on the agenda commerce and all the initiatives you guys have. I guess one of the concerns that I've been hearing quite a bit about from investors is just how people might gamify rewards and allocate their spending to the highest rewards benefit. So to the extent that that would happen, how would you guys adjust your model? Or is there something that you guys can do offensively to stay on the offensive? Thank you. Thanks for the question, Sanjay. I think, look, customers have always had the ability to optimize across carts. and our strategy really hasn't been to really compete simply on points or rational rewards. And I think the other thing that's important to understand is we really don't have a breakage model. So we don't benefit when people don't use our rewards. I think that when you think about the closed loop and the ability to even match our card members' desires and our merchants' desires, I think that gives us a huge advantage. And I think our overall model is so much more than just about points. It's access. It's service. It is security, which I think service and security in AI is going to be even more important. And it's one of the reasons that when I When I decided what we were going to talk about today, everybody, you know, talks about AI from an efficiency perspective and expense reduction productivity, which is very, very important. But what I wanted to do was to sort of demonstrate across the five key dimensions how it will actually be an accelerator for us. And the last thing I'll say is when we've had gamification or when we've had people that do certain things, we have levers within our model and we've shown this with the Platinum Card. where we can get to spend thresholds that require those benefits to be made, which then sort of eliminates that ability to game the system. So I think we have a lot of tools at our disposal, but I think the most important tool we have at our disposal is our card members that love our product and love what our product does for them. But again, like anything else, we'll see how it all plays out.
Donna
Operator
Thank you. The next question is coming from Ryan Nash of Goldman Sachs. Please go ahead.
Steve Squeri
Chairman and CEO
Good morning, everyone. Good morning, Ryan. Good morning, Steve.
spk02
How are you? Great to hear. So as you think about spend across the company, Christophe obviously spoke about the strength versus history. Maybe just talk about what you're seeing. Can you maintain this kind of level? And then given Christophe's comments regarding the moderating of VCEs, can we just talk big picture about the potential for Meet Teens EPS into next year and your confidence in it? Thank you.
Christophe Le Caillec
Chief Financial Officer
So let me start with that. So on the VCE, so the VCE is performing as we expected. And as you know, this quarter is the quarter we're going to have the Platinum Refresh, which is You know, the event that created this step up in the VCE ratio. So as you think about going forward, and Q4 is going to be a good example for that, you should expect that VCE ratio to kind of like stabilize in this kind of rate. But the growth rate in terms of the VCE dollars to moderate significantly and either to be more consistent with what we saw pre-refresh and, you know, we're not going to get into the guidance for 2027 at this stage. You're going to have to wait for January for that. But, you know, like that is going to help us, you know, just like, you know, maintain that meeting CPS ambition that we have been using for years to, you know, to think about the performance of this company. So I feel good about that. And I will say, I will add one more point of either on the VCE, Steve's comment here. We introduced this quarter amount-based redemption, which is like a very convenient way for card members to redeem their points. And we saw a very strong takeoff for this. So convenience is also a very important feature here in terms of those VCE and our ability to control that expense. In terms of the spend, there is a bit of noise this quarter because of the impact coming from the sale of this co-brand portfolio. So that creates some discontinuity in the trends. Obviously, we have a lot more information that you have. But when we control for that, we're very pleased with that, with those trends. In this US consumer segment, we're reporting this This quarter, 9.4% spend growth. It is the third highest we've seen over the last three years. And that is despite the timing of the Amazon Prime Days. And it's not only Amazon, as a matter of fact, because, you know, large retailers, you know, kind of like follow the similar schedule. So despite that headwind that kind of like, you know, created a lift in Q2 and a bit of a, you know, that were trained in Q3. We're seeing 9.4% billing growth and very strong growth in discretionary categories such as T&E and airline. So, you know, a lot of momentum and strength in our billings.
Steve Squeri
Chairman and CEO
Yeah, the only good thing I'd say is that, you know, as Christophe said, airline spending was really high. Restaurant spending continues, you know, to be high. It was up 9%. It's the largest T.A. category, but just to highlight, resi restaurants were up 18%. And then when you go and look at the fine hotels and resorts and the hotel collection, that's up 50%. So that's just another example of when you marry our card members with our merchants through our programs, how you just get more than one plus one equals two. Those are the kind of things that I think will continue to help drive growth for us as well.
Donna
Operator
Thank you. The next question is coming from Don Fandetti of Wells Fargo. Please go ahead.
spk06
Good morning. Thank you. If you look at the banks, they're just continuing to press hard into the premium segment, adding billions to the marketing budgets. I wanted to just get your sense on How are you thinking about market share and U.S. consumer? And then can you comment on the moderation in the international bill business?
Steve Squeri
Chairman and CEO
Yes, let me go with the second one first. You know, look, it's 22 straight quarters of double-digit growth rate in international. You know, we went from 13 to 11. We'll see how that plays out. But, you know, 11% growth is still very strong growth. And You know, the demographic from a card acquisition perspective, which still continues to be strong, is predominantly, you know, millennials and Gen Z. As far as the competitive frame, you know, look, the competitive frame, it really hasn't changed all that much. I mean, people, you know, there's a lot more, I think there's a lot more talk about it now, but It's been a battle for 10 years. And, you know, people continue to step up their game, but we continue to step up our game as well. And so, you know, obviously we've increased our marketing budget over time, but as a result of that, we've also increased our revenue. And let me also be clear about one thing. When we look at the premium segment, we're looking from a revenue perspective. And what we're looking for is sort of that three-lane stool, right? Obviously we drive spend. We drive tremendous card fee income. We're at $3 billion for the quarter, up 17% year over year, and we continue down that path. Obviously, our premium card members want to revolve, and they are revolving, and we're taking advantage of that. Not only are we taking advantage of that, but we take advantage of that with best-in-class credit performance. You know, I think that the challenge or the thing that we continue to face is continue to innovate. And I think we've been doing that. We've been doing that, as you see, across multiple segments, whether it's how we're embedding AI within some of the value propositions, the Airbnb announcement yesterday, which we're very excited about. and then, you know, you just look from a corporate and a small business perspective. And so, yeah, it's competitive and, you know, it keeps us on our toes, but we continue to do well and we're getting a share of revenue that we're looking to get and the results show that.
Donna
Operator
Thank you. The next question is coming from Erica Najarian of UBS. Please go ahead.
Operator
Conference Call Operator
Hi, thank you so much for taking my question. Hello. Steve, we really appreciate that you sort of addressed, you know, the topic at hand, up front. Rewards, Max, was not part of my look on until recently. I guess I'm wondering, you know, given that you're planning to be at the forefront of AI, you know, does that lead us to conclude that, you know, unlike some financial institutions that are blocking access from the bots, You will allow AI to be part of the ecosystem and therefore allow your members to help them maximize their experience. Is there sort of a financial measure that investors can think of when thinking about the future impact? Whether it's helping us understand how much of the benefits are already used or optimized and if AI increases that enjoyment of benefits. Is that impact disease percentage, but then there's a revenue offset? I guess investors are also thinking about what the financial impact could be of this rewards-backing trend.
Steve Squeri
Chairman and CEO
Let me give you my perspective on AI law. I'll just try to summarize some of the things I said. I think when You take a step back, you have to embrace it, and you have to do what your customers want to do. Having said that, I think in terms of, you've heard a lot about banks that are blocking, and look, we're going to take a risk-based approach too. We're just not going to let a citizen run rogue through our systems. That's not going to happen. We need to protect our customers, merchants, and We're only going to allow agents to access our systems that are either approved through API or MCP channels. We're also focused on providing a very consistent membership experience, meaning we don't want AI agents to be pinging Resi every four seconds and this is damaging our other partners. Can we slow them along? Okay. Anyway, so we're going to be selectively selectively looking at agents and how they act. Having said that, and as I said within my remarks earlier, I think there's going to be opportunities for us to embed our own agents within AI platforms. We're doing that today. And what we want to do is make sure that on these AI platforms, our assets are discoverable, much like we're doing with open AI, You know, with Resi and like we'll do with our own things like Wish Builder. I think in terms of rewards maximization, we've got a lot of gaming today that goes on and, you know, it's part of the overall mix. But I think with AI... As it might allow people to gain a little more, it also will allow us to manage it a little bit better as well by using AI tools to understand what people are doing and then how do we modify our value proposition. You've seen us do this. You've seen us do this with a $75,000 limit in terms of the passes for the planning part, and you'll see other controls that are put into the system. I think it's a little too early in the game to determine what the impact will be on VCE. But what I also would say is, you know, when you look at the entire model, partner engagement is so important to us. And as people continue to engage with our benefits, we tend to get a higher share of wallet, we get better credit benefits out of this, and I think ultimately engagement leads to a better outcome for us.
Donna
Operator
Thank you. The next question is coming from Bill Kakashi of Piper Sandler. Please go ahead.
spk13
Hey, Bill. Hey, good morning. So you guys have faced many ways of competition for premium card members in the past, but I'd love your thoughts on any changes you might be seeing in the competitive intensity in the current environment.
spk02
Does it feel any different today, particularly with players like Capital One now operating a closed loop
spk13
You know, generating higher returns and having historically demonstrated a willingness to step up in investments to prioritize their long-term positioning, even if that means compromising your term profitability. Just really love any insights that you can share on what you're watching there. That would be great.
Steve Squeri
Chairman and CEO
I mean, look, I think, you know, Citi, Capital One, Chase, everybody is sort of playing in this space. To be honest, we really don't see much difference than what we've seen. It's highly competitive. It's been highly competitive. And our assumption is that it will remain highly competitive. And it's highly competitive because it's a very profitable segment of the card base. The other thing I think that this competition does, which a lot of people lose focus of, there's a subset of card members that have Premium characteristics, but don't look at themselves as premium card members necessarily. And so it introduced more people into that part of the TAM, which may not have been there before. They're creditworthy enough, but they weren't participating with those products and services. And I think that's worked out well for everybody.
Donna
Operator
Thank you. Our next question is coming from Rob Wilde, HACCP Autonomous Research. Please go ahead.
spk02
Hi, guys.
spk10
Hey, Rob. Hey, Rob.
spk09
I wanted to ask about the allowance-subverage ratio in the context of the growth in NII lending balances down to 2.6 now. You have this piece of model adjustment remaking the higher-end borrowers, and we can see the scenario in the back of the deck, but I guess the question is how much does the 2.6 reflect Any conservatism with respect to the broader environment or maybe ask the question another way. Is there any color you can give what you think like a normal environment allowance coverage ratio might be?
Christophe Le Caillec
Chief Financial Officer
So I'll take that question. So yes, in the appendix we're showing in a simplified way the scenarios, the economic scenarios we're using, and I guess you're focusing on You know, the downside scenario, I don't have the numbers in front of me, but I think we're assuming like some kind of like peak unemployment in the like 8% range, right? And so it's a pretty aggressive scenario. Listen, you know, the fundamental dynamic here and why their reserve rate is at 2.6 and it's below where we were when we introduced CECL, I think it was in 2020. The key dynamic here is the premiumization of the portfolio. As we focus more on fee-paying card members, as we focus more on VCE, we are attracting card members that have a great credit profile and that are slowly improving the credit metrics across the portfolio. You see that as well in their in the write-off rate that we're reporting this quarter and the delinquency rate. The delinquency rate are not only best in class, they've been stable at 1.2%, 1.3% for 15 quarters, right? And, you know, when you look at by vintage, you know, the new vintages are performing better from a credit standpoint than the past vintages. And you can track that again to, you know, their positive selection that happens in our acquisition marketing engine. Another metric that we report every quarter is the percentage of those new accounts joining the franchise on a fee-paying product, which is a good indicator as well of the premiumness of that vintage. And it's the highest I think we've seen since we reported that metric at 76%, right? And so fundamentally, Rob, what's happening here is that, of course, we are very disciplined in our underwriting decisions, but Safely, but surely the portfolio is getting more and more premium by the day. And we keep, you know, we haven't changed the kind of like economic scenarios that we use in terms of, you know, the conservative scenario over the past years. And, you know, that's what's driving, you know, the performance on CECL.
Donna
Operator
Thank you. The next question is coming from John Pancari of Evercore ISI. Please go ahead.
spk01
Good morning. Good morning, John. I'm just on the card fee front. I know you noted last quarter that card fees should grow in high teams in the fourth quarter. You didn't seem to put that in your slide deck this quarter, but I believe, Steve, you just mentioned that you should continue down that path in that you mentioned the 17%. The third quarter. So is there any change there in how you're thinking about the fourth quarter or how you think about maybe if you can also elaborate on, I know you're not giving 27 yet, but how you're thinking about that pace as you progress through 27, just given the dynamics that you're seeing in the space. Thanks.
Christophe Le Caillec
Chief Financial Officer
Yeah, so I'll take the question, John. Good morning. So on the card fee, you might remember we entered the year saying you should expect a downward trend or moderation in terms of the growth rate. and then in the end of the year, the second half of the year, you should expect an inflection point and exit in the high teens. We saw that inflection point this quarter, right? And you saw it like we were at 15% in Q2 and this quarter we are at 17% effects adjusted. So that's the inflection point that we were expecting and that we saw. I'm not gonna give you guidance about how to think about this 2027 Again, you're going to have to wait until January for that. And we also don't give quarterly guidance on card fee. But if you take a step back, performance on this line has been amazing since 2019, since we started focusing more of our energy investments, innovation towards premium products and fee-paying experiences and customers. And that 17% is amazing. The fact that we are able to accelerate the game is remarkable. And it's the fastest growing line we have in the P&L. And it's definitely a key contributor as well to their very strong ROE performance. So we're going to keep focusing on this. And we'll update you in terms of how to think about that growth rate when we get to 2027 at the beginning of the year.
Donna
Operator
Thank you. The next question is coming from Terry Ma of Barclays. Please go ahead.
spk12
Hi, Terry. Good morning, Terry. Hey, good morning. Thank you. So you've talked in the past about the opportunities to capture more borrowing share from your existing premium customers. Are you seeing any meaningful change in revolved behavior? And just how much more runway do you see to grow lending faster without changing the credit profile of the franchise?
Christophe Le Caillec
Chief Financial Officer
In terms of the borrowing, I don't think we report regularly our penetration rate here, but it has been stable, I would say, over the past years. What matters to us is that we meet the needs of our con members. If they want to borrow, we're there for them. If they don't want to borrow, then so be it. We don't need them to borrow for us to have a profitable relationship. That has been our mantra for years. It remains our mantra. and of course NII plays an important role in our economics but we're not changing our underwriting approach here and what we've seen as well in terms of penetrating the wallet of our COD members is that the better you know like the more spend we capture and you know the more premium the product is the more likely we are to capture the revolve and to meet the revolving needs of our COD members so Our strategy remains the same, right? Serve our customer the best way we can, focus on premium customers, meet their borrowing needs when they have some, and that's our approach. We are not kind of like targeting a specific number in terms of NII or in terms of AR balances.
Donna
Operator
Thank you. The next question is coming from Darren Peller of Wolf Research. Please go ahead.
spk12
Good morning. Morning, John.
spk00
Hey, good morning, guys. Thanks. Can you just retouch again on the competitive landscape around commercial for a moment? I know you mentioned a bit more about premium, but just revisiting your initiatives, what kind of progress and milestones you'd like to see in terms of some element of an acceleration potential in the overall segment volume, and then maybe just business milestones as well as you integrate more of the platforms you've run on. Thanks.
Steve Squeri
Chairman and CEO
Yeah, so I think that when you look at the commercial space, there's really three segments. One we call SME, but it's really small, and it's also middle, and then you've got corporate. I think small continues to perform very, very strong, and we're doing quite well there. I think our cashback product that we launched a couple quarters ago, last quarter, the graphite product has performed a lot better than we even anticipated it performing. I think then you have the large and the multinational, and that continues to be a real sweet spot for us. And it's growing exactly as we would expect it to grow. I mean, that's traditionally a T&E piece. I think where the competitive piece is, is really within the middle market piece there. And that's where I think, from our perspective, we have not grown the way we want to grow. And that's why we did the center acquisition. and with the center acquisition and the platform that that sits on as NOVA, the launch of our business savings account, the launch of our corporate cash back program, corporate liability within that segment. These are things that we needed to more effectively compete with RAMP and with Brex. And I think those are two of the big competitors that are out there. And what they unlocked in this segment was sort of the automation and the expense management piece of this. And then obviously the introduction of agents within. And so what you'll see from us as we move forward, you will see the introduction into this platform of more agents that will help middle and larger businesses do their work. And you will see us then sort of make all of these products and services available to the back book. And so I think it'll take a little bit of, it'll continue to take a little bit of time, but we feel we are not only a better position than we were at this time a year ago, but we're also got the roadmap as we move forward here to continue to make these capabilities available to a wider base of our middle market and large customers.
Donna
Operator
Thank you. The next question is coming from Mihir Bhatia of Bank of America. Please go ahead.
spk10
Hi, Mihir. Good morning. Hi. Good morning. Thank you for taking my question. I wanted to maybe ask, touch on the Visa MasterCard settlement that's been in the news again this week, you know, with expectations that it might get approved soon. So I wanted to ask specifically for you all in terms of, I guess a two-part question. One is just in terms of the settlement, and if it relaxes, as it relaxes on all cards, expands surcharging, do you expect there to be a change in merchant behavior from that? And how are you thinking about the competitive implications proposed from that supplement? And part of the reason I asked is it feels like there's been momentum in your network business this year with more pure network types. Deals being announced, whether it was NFL or Lowe's, and I think there was another one last week. So I'm just wondering if you're rethinking your network business and the implications of the settlement. Thank you.
Steve Squeri
Chairman and CEO
Okay. So I think, look, I think from a network perspective, I think we've really pivoted from a strategy in that we're looking at and I'll try and say this the best way possible, but we're not looking to partner with the bigger banks. I think we made a lot of efforts to attempt to partner with some of the bigger banks that didn't really pay off for us. And I think, you know, whether we're now partnering with Synchrony or we're partnering with Bread Financial or we're partnering with others, I think it's allowing us to reach more segments of the population that we traditionally wouldn't reach. We will continue to see, I believe, more and more of those deals be done. Not bigger deals with big banks, but probably some smaller to mid-sized banks with specific entities. And so people like the brand and we offer a lot of value. And I think with Bread Financial, the synergy there between our NFL deal and their NFL partnership. It just made all the sense in the world for us to do business with them and we respect them a lot. As far as the Visa MasterCard settlement, we're going to have to see how that all plays out. But look, surcharging is pretty much a fact of life at small businesses right now. Doesn't really appear to have affected anybody's business. If anything, it's not a great experience for consumers. and it aggravates consumers when they see it. And so that's number one, but I don't think that really has affected anybody's momentum at this point. As far as honor roll cards, good luck. It's gonna be really hard, I think, for people to differentiate. And if you wanna see a consumer backlash, If you think about one Visa card over another Visa card, MasterCard, so forth and so on, I think you'll have a lot of consumer outrage with that. But again, we'll see how that all plays out in the marketplace. But more to see here. Thank you.
Donna
Operator
Our final question today is coming from Chris Kennedy of William Blair. Please go ahead.
spk11
Good morning. Thanks for taking the question. I think maybe 10% of your U.S. customers have a deposit account with American Express, and I recall digital banking was a key area of investment for you guys. Can you just talk about that journey and kind of the role of banking products going forward?
Steve Squeri
Chairman and CEO
Yeah, well, you have the statistic exactly correct. I think You know, one of the things that we really try and do with our customers is expand the organic core and banking services are part of that core. And if you think about understanding someone's credit worthiness, understanding and building a bigger relationship with them, I think banking services is more important. We're on a journey as it relates to banking services. You want to make sure you get this right. You want to make sure you have the right controls in place and and everything else. And so I think you'll see this continue to play a bigger part in our overall strategy in not only engaging with our card members, but acquiring card members. And I think there is more to come here, but even with just the launch this quarter of the business savings account for our small business customers, it's another step in that direction.
Kartik Ramachandran
Head of Investor Relations
Great. Thanks, Steve. With that, we will bring the call to an end. Thank you for joining us and for your interest in American Express.
Donna
Operator
Ladies and gentlemen, that concludes today's conference call. Thank you for participating. You may now disconnect.