BJ BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc.
$110.75
BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc. Q3 F2026 Earnings Call Transcript
AI Conference Call Analysis
Sign in or subscribe to read.Conference Operator
Operator
Hello, everyone. Thank you for joining us and welcome to BJ's Wholesale Club third quarter 2026 earnings conference call. After today's prepared remarks, we will host a question and answer session. If you would like to ask a question, please press star one to raise your hand. To withdraw your question, press star one again. I will now hand the conference over to Diana Rashkow, Vice President of Investor Relations. Diana, please go ahead.
Diana Rashkow
Vice President of Investor Relations
Good morning and welcome to BJ's third quarter fiscal 2026 earnings call. Joining me today are Bob Eddy, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, Laura Felice, Chief Financial Officer, and Bill Werner, Chief Development Officer. Please remember that we may make forward-looking statements on this call that are based on our current expectations. Forward-looking statements are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from what we say on this call. Please see the risk factors section of our most recent SEC filings for a description of these risks and uncertainties. Please also refer to today's press release and latest investor presentation posted on our investor relations website for our cautionary statement regarding forward-looking statements and non-GAAP reconciliation. And now I'll turn the call over to Bob.
Bob Eddy
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
Thank you and good morning, everyone. Thanks for joining us today. I'm proud to say we delivered a terrific quarter that came in well ahead of our expectations. Net sales grew 18% and comparable club sales, excluding gasoline, were up 4.1%. Before I get into the details, let me explain how we approached this quarter. It starts with who we are. 42 years ago, we opened our first club in Medford, Massachusetts. The club model was a new idea at the time, but the core idea of leveraging cost savings to deliver value back to customers is a concept as old as retail itself. Today, we serve more than 8.5 million members in 271 clubs across 22 states. A lot has changed since 1984, but what we do and why we do it hasn't. We take care of the families who depend on us. That purpose is how we run this business. It's how we show up for everyone who relies on BJs, our members, our team members, our communities, and our shareholders. Whether it's assortment decisions, a holiday promotional strategy, or how we negotiate indirect costs, it is all with the goal of investing back into the member experience and pouring outsized value back into our members. These everyday decisions are what drive the lifetime value base of our business. While we operate in that fashion every day, every so often a moment comes along that calls for something bigger, a chance to do something our members, team members, communities, and shareholders would remember. This quarter was that moment. As we announced in early September, we reached a litigation settlement that resulted in a one-time pre-tax benefit of approximately $240 million. We did not view the settlement as just an amount of cash. We viewed it as an opportunity to invest in BJ's stakeholders, and we chose to play offense with it. We built an ambitious plan to accelerate our strategy in ways that were fun and engaging, and we executed it on a tight timeline. I'm pleased to say it has been a resounding success. And what matters most is not the great results in the quarter. It is that results should build over time. More loyal members, an engaged team, connections to our communities, and value for our shareholders. Let me take you through the investments in more detail. We started with our members viewing the investment as a thank you for decades of loyalty. The centerpiece was our 42nd birthday event, where we offered 42% off featured items throughout the club. Our merchants chose those items carefully, focusing on what matters most to our members. There were everyday staples that members buy week in and week out, like ground beef, chicken drumsticks, and apples. There were Wellesley Farms favorites, like hummus, deli ham, and coffee, so members could try our own brands at an even lower price. There were fun and seasonal items like a kid's pedal go-kart and outerwear. And there were a few splurges like Wagyu steaks and KitchenAid mixers, things that members might not otherwise buy for themselves. We supported it with the most ambitious marketing campaign we've ever run, from traditional media like direct mail, TV, and radio, to a drone show over New York City. The buzz spread on social, too, with unpaid content generating millions of views. We wanted our members to feel celebrated. That means great prices on the things their families love and a reason to treat themselves a little. Our members loved it. They showed up and filled their carts. Comp traffic increased by 6% year over year during the nearly six-week promotion, levels we have not seen since 2020. We know that engagement drives loyalty. There is a direct link between trips and renewal rate. In fact, tenured members who shop with us once a month have a renewal rate of more than 95%. Comp units grew by 9% during the promotion. Members purchased more than 500,000 pieces of outerwear and enough ground beef to make more than 30 million burgers. Both of those categories sold three times their normal volumes. We also saw tremendous trial of new categories. For example, more than 100,000 members bought coffee from us for the first time. And just like trips, the more units and categories a member buys, the more loyal they become. Even better, the members who responded most are the ones with the most room to grow. The biggest jump in shopping frequency came from our newer and less engaged members. and our most frequent shoppers who account for the bulk of the sales came in more often too. Membership drives trips, trips drive renewals, and we've seen that flywheel work year after year. In tandem with the birthday event, we made investments to accelerate our progress in a few key strategic areas. We ran a membership acquisition campaign with new programs and special pricing tied to the celebration. We offered targeted discounts to encourage members to try our own brands. And we gave members an incentive to get started with Express Pay. I'll share what we're seeing from these initiatives in a few minutes when I walk through our strategic priorities. Next, I want to talk about our team members. We invested across the full organization because every great team member experience starts with our team. In particular, I want to highlight the awards we made to our more than 30,000 hourly team members. In October, as part of celebrating our 42nd birthday, we surprised team members in our clubs and distribution centers with the largest recognition award in our company's history. The awards were based on tenure, which was our way of thanking our team members for their loyalty, just like we thanked our members for theirs. These team members are the lifeblood of BJs. They are the most important team members in our company as they are on the front lines providing superior service to our members and delivering our purpose every day. It was truly an honor and one of the proudest days of my career to be able to personally hand out BJ's gift cards to our team members to recognize them and thank them. There were more than a few tears shed when I visited our Royal Palm Beach, Florida club, and each member of our executive team had similar reactions in the clubs they visited. While I'm on this topic, I'd like to take this opportunity to say one more time to our team members in the clubs and distribution centers. We appreciate everything you do day in and day out in support of our members, our company, and our purpose. Thank you. Taking care of families doesn't stop at our club doors. It extends to the communities in which we live and work. This quarter, we also made significant contributions to support those communities. just as we have throughout the last four decades. We will set a record this year for our community giving as we've supported hundreds of organizations and communities across our footprint. As we head into the holidays, I'm proud of how we're showing up in our communities. Just in the past few weeks, we've funded weekend and school break meals for kids near our Fort Worth Club, and we've helped fund holiday meals in Buffalo. We're also working to bring holiday cheer to patients and their families in children's hospitals across our footprint. Those are just a few examples of how we are taking care of the families who depend on us. Most importantly, the investments we made this year underscore our commitment to making a positive impact in our communities in the years and decades to come. Let me turn now to our shareholders. As you know, in November 2024, our board approved a new $1 billion share repurchase authorization, which runs through January 2029. Year to date, we've repurchased more than $366 million of our shares, our largest annual amount since going public, with a quarter still to go. Taking care of the families who depend on us has always been how we build long-term value for our shareholders. Every added unit, trip, new member, own branch trial, and express pay adopter makes that engine stronger, adding to our membership base and the earnings it generates. And we expect the benefits to extend well beyond this quarter. As we closed out the birthday event on October 31st, we moved right into the holiday season. Our early Black Friday event and free Thanksgiving turkey promotion are helping families prepare, host, and give. And we've added some fun surprises this season, new items members may not have seen before at BJ's. Turning to the broader environment, our consumer remains resilient. This quarter, more members shopped with us and spent more across every income level, with a growing share choosing higher-tier memberships. We also continued to gain share. Based on Circana data and the markets in which we operate, the rest of the market saw unit sales decline during Q3 while we saw unit gains. Our units grew more than 500 basis points faster than the market during the quarter. That includes the lift from our birthday event, but the lead isn't new. We've outpaced the market on units over the entire year. Our model is built to grow both sales and units by delivering value. and we're doing both faster than the market. Gasoline continues to be a great share gain story with total gallons up 20% and comp gallons increasing by 11% during the quarter. This is one of the clearest ways we deliver value to our members, especially in times of elevated prices. We offer real savings when they need it most and this offering is a big reason more of them are choosing BJ's. Now let me update you on our strategic priorities, which are how we deliver on our purpose every day. We invest in them with confidence because we know the results build over time. I want to focus on how our recent investments support these efforts. Let me start with membership, the foundation of our business, which by all metrics remains extremely strong. MFI grew by 9.5% in the third quarter, which continues to track above our initial expectations for the year. As I mentioned earlier, in conjunction with our birthday event, we made a targeted push to attract new members. We signed up more than 200,000 new members in October alone, nearly 40% above our average month earlier this year. The combination of comp club membership growth of 2% to 3%, strong new member sign-ups, record renewal rates, and higher tier penetration means we now expect MFI growth of approximately 7.5% as we exit the year. Membership fee income is the highest quality revenue stream in our model. It's recurring, it's highly profitable, and it reflects our members' confidence in the value we deliver. Every member who joins, renews, or moves up to a higher tier adds to a stream that builds over time. That's why we were so deliberate about bringing in new members during our birthday event and why the benefits extend well beyond this quarter. Our own brands were a big part of the story, too. In October, we ran our largest own brands trial campaign with discounts sent specifically to members who hadn't tried our own brands in a category before. Members redeemed those offers about 670,000 times. and 11% of the units we sold on those items went to members trying them for the first time. In addition to the coffee I mentioned before, members especially loved our Wellesley Farms products like our cashews and olive oil. We're confident that once members try a great product at a great price, they'll come back for it. Quality and value are what keep members engaged and that builds loyalty and lifetime value. I also want to tell you more about our assortment work. Last quarter, I told you about our commitment to reduce our SKU count by about 20%, and today I want to tell you how we will get there. We've planned several waves of our category management process, or CMP, over the next two years or so. With each wave, we are reducing redundant SKUs and reallocating space to create room for innovation, more excitement, and greater exposure to growing categories. We made meaningful progress repositioning several health and beauty aids categories and saw strong results in Q3. Late in the quarter, we also launched a grocery reset that reduced SKU count, introduced new items, and made significant changes to space allocation, prioritizing high-growth snacking categories and high-protein options such as meat snacks. Initial results are encouraging and we plan to deploy additional resets using this approach in Q1 and Q2 of next year and beyond. We believe that in the next year or so, our members will see a notable improvement in the quality and the clarity of our assortment. That means an easier and more exciting shopping trip and more reasons to come back. Turning to convenience, Digital-enabled comp sales grew 38% in the quarter. In Q3, we made a targeted effort to drive Express Pay adoption. We know that members who use Express Pay shop more, spend more, and renew at higher rates, and our efforts are working. Express Pay order penetration increased by more than 200 basis points throughout the quarter. We're also building for the future. Bev, our AI Shopping Assistant, continues to gain momentum and is becoming part of how members shop and get help. And she's now in our app. Those conversations also tell us what members want, which helps our team act on it. And as AI platforms evolve, we're meeting members where they are, building the capabilities to show up and shop with us in the AI assistance they're starting to use. And finally, our footprint. New clubs remain a key engine of our long-term growth. In Q3, we relocated our Rotterdam, New York club and opened new clubs in Foley, Alabama and Ocala, Florida, all with new gas stations. So far in November, we opened our fifth Texas club in Mesquite, as well as in Frankfort, Kentucky. We have three additional club openings in store for the rest of the quarter in Lakanto and Port St. Lucie, Florida, and Portage, Indiana. as well as two gas stations being added to existing club locations. The performance of our new club portfolio remains strong with ROICs in the high teens. We also have our strongest pipeline yet with nearly 30 new clubs planned for 2027 and 2028, including a new club coming to the Bronx next year. We are now running hard in real estate growth and beyond 2028, we want to challenge ourselves to go even faster. Before I hand it over to Laura, I want to say a few words about our team. This was a busy quarter with a lot of moving pieces, and it all came together because of the people in our clubs, distribution centers, supply chain, and club support center who showed up every day to make it happen. I'm proud of what we accomplished together, and I'm grateful to every one of you. Laura, over to you.
Laura Felice
Chief Financial Officer
Thank you, Bob, and good morning, everyone. I'd like to add my thanks to our team members across the company for an outstanding quarter. Let me begin with our sales results. Net sales were $6.1 billion, up 17.7% year over year. Comparable club sales, including gasoline, were up 13.5%, and excluding gasoline, they were up 4.1%. Traffic drove the majority of our comp growth during the quarter. Turning to our categories, grocery, perishables, and sundries comp was up 3.4% fled by grocery. General merchandise and services grew 9.1% with growth across home, seasonal, apparel, consumer electronics, and services. Inflation was just under a point for the quarter after adjusting for the 42nd birthday promotional activity. In gas, comp gallons increased 10.6%, and we continued to take share. Industry data indicates overall comp fuel gallons declined by about 5%. Membership fee income increased 9.5% to $138 million as we continued to grow our base of more than 8.5 million members, maintained strong renewal rates, and drove higher tier penetration. As Bob noted, while we expect MFI growth to moderate as the impact of last year's fee increase fully normalizes, we now expect to exit the year at around 7.5% growth. Turning to gross profit. In total, we delivered $1.02 billion in gross profit dollars up 1% over last year, even as we invested in our members. Within that, merchandise gross margin rate was down 170 basis points year over year, driven by an estimated $56 million of one-time promotions related to our 42nd birthday. fully funded by the interchange settlement. Turning to fuel, penny profit was approximately in line with our forecasted rate. Combined with strong gallon growth, fuel gross profit was just slightly ahead of our targeted level for the quarter. SG&A was $696 million on a reported basis, which includes $240 million of legal settlement benefit, partially offset by an estimated $95 million of in-quarter investments in compensation, advertising, and labor that Bob described. As a result, adjusted EBITDA was $422 million, Our effective tax rate was 27.4%. Adjusted EPS was $1.73 ahead of our expectation, driven by the great performance and aided by legal settlement benefit partially offset by our in-quarter investments. Turning to our balance sheet and cash flow, merchandise inventory ended the quarter at $1.84 billion up 9% year-over-year, reflecting our new club openings and more normalized inventory levels compared to the prior year as we head into the holidays. Our comp inventory balance is clean with good in-stock levels. Our balance sheet remains strong with total debt of $469 million, cash of $29 million, and net debt to adjusted EBITDA of .3 times. Cash flow remained healthy. Year-to-date cash flow from operations was $933 million, up from $639 million last year. Capital expenditures net of disposal were $592 million, reflecting continued investment in our new clubs and our distribution network. Adjusted free cash flow was $455 million year-to-date compared to $141 million last year and $232 million in the third quarter. Our capital allocation priorities remain unchanged. First and foremost, we invest in the business, in membership, merchandising, digital capabilities, and real estate. We also continue to return capital to shareholders. In the third quarter, we repurchased $35.6 million of our shares, bringing the year-to-date total to $366.3 million. And we have approximately $387 million remaining under existing authorization. Now let me turn to the outlook for the full year. We're pleased with our outperformance in the third quarter, and we've updated our guidance to reflect it. We are raising our full year guidance for comparable club sales growth, excluding gasoline, to 2.5% to 3%. For adjusted earnings per share, we are raising our range, and we now expect $5.10 to $5.30 for the full year. This range reflects our strong performance along with the net benefit of the legal settlement after the investments we made in the quarter. We're pleased with how the third quarter came together and we entered the holiday season with a clear plan and a strong foundation. As always, our outlook reflects our current view of the consumer and the broader operating environment. and we will continue to manage the business with discipline while investing for long-term growth. With that, I'll turn it back to Bob.
Bob Eddy
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
Thanks, Laura. Before we open the call for questions, I want to take a step back. This was a strong quarter, well ahead of our expectations. We were handed a rare opportunity and we chose to play offense and invest in our future and were guided by our purpose in doing so. We celebrated our members, we honored our team, we stood with our communities, and we kept building long-term value for our shareholders. We did it the way we've always done it, because that is our job. Our strategic priorities are working, and the investments we made this quarter were designed to accelerate each of them. We're excited about the road ahead. Thank you to our members, our team members, our communities, and our shareholders for being a part of it. All of it comes back to why we are here. We take care of the families who depend on us. That's who we are. That's what we do. And we're still just getting started. With that, let's take your questions.
Conference Operator
Operator
We will now begin the question and answer session. Please limit yourself to one question and one follow-up. If you would like to ask a question, please press star one on your telephone keypad. To withdraw your question, press star one again. We ask that you pick up your handset when asking a question, and if you're muted locally, please remember to unmute your device. Your first question comes from the line of Kate McShane from Goldman Sachs. Please go ahead.
Kate McShane
Analyst, Goldman Sachs
Hi, good morning. Thanks for taking our question. I guess we were curious just with regards to the sustainability of some of this momentum that you saw during the third quarter. It does seem like a lot of the efforts did result in quite a bit of growth. What have you seen since maybe the ending of the anniversary sale in terms of response? And again, just how should we think about the sustainability of demand beyond the anniversary sale?
Bob Eddy
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
Hi, Kate. Good morning. Thanks for your question. You know, we're pretty excited to share the results that we put out this morning. I'm really proud of the team for getting it all done. We've really never done anything of this scope and speed and maybe more importantly, impact on our company. And we really like the feeling. And, you know, I hope that these investments feel aggressive to you because that was our goal. We did terrific work on behalf of our members during COVID, but my opinion was we didn't invest enough of that unanticipated upside. When we got this legal settlement this quarter, we really tried to do the right thing with that and invested over $150 million during the quarter to try and really get our company moving faster and to accelerate our strategy. We drove unprecedented engagement with our membership. was obviously the comp upside and the traffic and the units that we talked about. We had the incredible engagement with our members and thanking them and rewarding them for their work. And obviously what we talked about from a community standpoint and from our shareholders as well. But your point is the best one. We did this not for any particular result in this quarter. We did it for the long-term value of what these efforts are. do for us. And it's our belief that the gains made in this quarter will drive lifetime value and will drive our company to be better in the future. You think about investing in our members, not only did we sign up well over a couple hundred thousand members, we talked about just 200,000 members in just October alone. So obviously that benefit will persist into the future. But we know that increased engagement, is a good thing from a lifetime value perspective. The more units people put in their basket, the more times they come to see us. The more times they come to see us, the more they renew their membership. Obviously, the more they renew, the more they come to see us again. It's a virtuous cycle that we can invest in over and over. In our past, maybe we haven't been so religious in doing so over time in response to whatever might be happening in a particular quarter or year, but I'm thrilled that we took the opportunity to really do that and build our company for the future. And so as we look forward, you can think about certain benefits that would persist. Obviously, I talked about the number of members. We know there's a direct link between trips and renewal rates. So we've seen better results in renewal rates during and following the promotional period. We know that the traffic continues to give people reasons to think about us and I believe will cause them to show up at increased rates in the future, both in this year and in the future next year. And so I'm really bullish on our ability for these games to be sustainable. Again, we didn't We didn't do it for one quarter's benefit here. We did it for that long term. And that thought continues into some of the other things that we did, right? Investing in own brands and investing in express pay. Those benefits are harder to see in any one particular quarter and really are meant to augur towards the future, right? I mean, we're giving somebody money to use express pay as, for instance, their first time. But we know that once they get into that, they shop more, they spend more, they come to see us more. Their net promoter score goes up quite considerably once they get into that franchise. And so while that may look like not the best ROI in this particular quarter, it will definitely look like a great ROI in the future. And so we're pretty happy with what we did. And I think you can look for us to do more of that in the future if we have the opportunity.
Kate McShane
Analyst, Goldman Sachs
Thank you. And I just wanted to follow up with a quick question on your Beyond 2028 real estate comment. Should we assume that you're contemplating opening more stores per year beyond 2028?
Bob Eddy
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
Yeah, look, I mean, I'll hand this over to Bill, but that's certainly our goal, right? We've gone from not opening any clubs to now, you know, reliably opening 10 to 15 a year. And We're experiencing fantastic returns. We talk about returns on capital in the mid to high teens. That's better than the S&P 500 average. It's certainly better than our cost of capital. That just screams at us, go faster. It takes a while to get the flywheel to go faster in this regard, but we'd love to open more if we can.
Bill Werner
Chief Development Officer
Bill? I think, Kate, what you saw say in the script is a little bit of signaling that we came out two years ago with a goal to accelerate to 25 to 30. I think what you're hearing today is that we're trying to trend towards the top end of that range as we look out for the next two years, so 27 to 28 combined. And as a team, we're working hard on what 29 and forward looks like now. Yeah, I've mentioned this on a couple of the earnings calls and in other investor meetings. It's, you know, the market's super dynamic. And with the share gains that we're seeing and, you know, the share gains were amazing across this past quarter, especially during the birthday celebration. But even now with sending like that one month across the board, we've seen, you know, crazy unit share gains, great dollar share gains. and every time we gain share, the models change in terms of opportunities for additional real estate. So it's just a really exciting time to be part of the real estate program here at BJ's and the team is super engaged and excited to do everything we can to drive value for new prospective members and new communities.
Conference Operator
Operator
Thank you. Your next question comes from the line of Peter Benedict from Baird. Please go ahead.
Peter Benedict
Analyst, Baird
Hey, guys. Good morning. So a couple questions. First, can you help us maybe unpack the Merch Margin decline quarter? You gave some points. I think you talked about maybe $54 million of reinvestment. I'm just curious how you can kind of unpack kind of the full 170 and how we think about the fourth quarter trends from a Merch Margin perspective. That's my first question.
Bob Eddy
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
Hi Pete, good morning. Thanks for your question. Maybe I'll start and Laura can fill in. I think our team did a fantastic job managing margin this quarter, particularly hard given all the different promotions and changes we were making. As you can imagine, the management was just a task in itself this quarter. We talked a little bit in the prepared remarks about The decline in margin rate being a result of all these promotions that we do, these one-time promotions. And so X that, the margin rate was about where we thought it was going to be and similar to what it was in Q2. I think what I would say is focusing on the rate loses the plot a little bit. We wanted to win by engaging the members with compelling merchandise with great values. And that means winning a little bit with margin dollars more than any one particular rate. And I think you should think about seeing us do that more and more as we go forward. This business is about membership and engagement and trips and units more than it is about any one particular rate. And we'd love to win through margin dollars more. It's better for our members and just fine for us. So, you know, maybe I'll hand it over to Laura, see if she can fill in.
Laura Felice
Chief Financial Officer
Yeah, you know, I think I would add on top of that, Pete, I think the question's a good one. Bob highlights, you know, we continue to manage the business for margin dollar accretion. Rate's important, but it doesn't always give the full picture. and so driving healthy penny profit to our business is really the aim of what we're doing. And so we invested dollars in the quarter. We think that was important. Bob already talked about how we're thinking about that as we move forward and how it feeds the membership flywheel. So that roughly $56 million that we talked about investing in the quarter, I think excluding that, our margin rates were healthy and they were on target and ahead of the promotion they were tracking where we thought they would be. You know, one-time promotional investments are often hard to isolate because their impact extends beyond the one-time promotion and into the broader membership shopping behavior. And so, again, we're really happy with the results we delivered. We're aiming at delivering gross profit margin dollars and holding together the whole P&L as we head into the fourth quarter and beyond.
Bob Eddy
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
Yeah, and maybe I'll just finish up. I mean, the legal settlement showed up in SG&A, Pete, but we viewed it as margin. We viewed it as our members' money, first and foremost. And so this quarter was really about giving them that benefit. and that's really what guided us when we knew the settlement was coming. We started crafting this program. How can we give this to our members for their benefit? Because we know that every time we give them a benefit, they in turn pay that back to us.
Peter Benedict
Analyst, Baird
Yep. No, strategy makes total sense. Thanks for that color. My follow-up is really just around any way to assess like any pull forward that you may have had from the event. I mean, obviously some great engagement there Since it's closed out, any sense that you had any pull-forward impacts? I'm just curious, you read on the early holiday trends, Thanksgiving, that type of thing. Thank you.
Bob Eddy
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
Yeah, good question. Anytime you see volume increases like we saw in the quarter, that's a risk. I think our merchants did a phenomenal job selecting the items that we promoted to minimize that impact. and so maybe answer it in two different ways. From a general merchandise perspective, we absolutely pulled things forward. And our aim there was really to take sales out of the market before they went to others. And so about hardware and KitchenAid mixers and things, we're thrilled that we got people in to buy those things, no matter what quarter it comes in. The fact that it came in Q3 gives us an opportunity to sell them something different in Q4. and may have stolen a sale from someone else. And in the food and grocery business, there's only so much you can put in your freezer. And so while we definitely sold a ton of ground beef and I'm sure people froze some of it and that might be pulled forward, you don't really do that with potatoes or apples or deli meat or some of the other things that we did. I'm sure there's some limited pull forward that will impact us going forward, but the more important story is the engagement, the trips, the units, the reasons we've given them to come back and see us in the future, and that we think will overwhelm any pull forward.
Peter Benedict
Analyst, Baird
Got it. Makes sense. Thanks, guys. Good luck. Good morning.
Conference Operator
Operator
Your next question comes from the line of Edward Kelly from Wells Fargo. Please go ahead.
Edward Kelly
Analyst, Wells Fargo
Yeah, good morning, everyone. Bob, I guess my question is on investment. It's good to see smart investment in the business yielding returns. And when you say things like the biggest jump happening with your less engaged members and you talk about 200,000 signups in October, which is really impressive, what is that telling you about BJs and the pace of investment or what you should be investing moving forward? And then as part of that, what's the promotional cadence look like in Q4. Have you saved any dollars to invest in Q4? I think you're going to have probably a strong fuel margin quarters, or maybe you have money to spend there. But just curious how you're thinking about Q4 as well.
Bob Eddy
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
Yeah. Morning, Ed. It's a good question. I guess let me start out by saying, again, we were thrilled with how our members reacted to this stuff. We were thrilled to have the opportunity to do it. and, you know, we've been talking for a while about this is club's time, right? Where members' wallets are pressured, consumers' wallets are pressured. We're among the lowest cost providers of grocery and general merchandise. And so we've been gathering share for a while. We've been a long-term share gainer and the club industry has as well. And so that's been the centerpiece of our strategy. How can we really take advantage of that? How can we build on that thought? The idea of making these huge investments in the third quarter was just a fun thing to really think about because in a normal quarter, we're trying to make the investments that work within the construct of RP&L and our commitments to Wall Street and what's going on in the broader market. We just had a greater pile of money to play with in this quarter. Importantly, we didn't really reduce what we were thinking about from a Q4 perspective. We didn't change that at all initially. We have been tweaking it based on some of the lessons that we learned in the Q3 promotions. And this idea that our members really responded to some of these things and this idea that we can make longer term bets than in any one quarter. And so I think you may see different types of promotions in the future. Not necessarily more or less dollars put against them than we might have otherwise planned, but we learned a lot in how to engage our members, what they will respond to, what's important to them. And it's in things big and small, like what's the depth of a particular promotion that matters? What types of things matter? I mean, I think if you asked us six months ago whether our members would buy Wagyu beef from us, we would probably have said no. and we decided to take a shot and see what happened and they bought it in droves and KitchenAid mixtures, same thing. We've had many years where we've tried to sell those things and they haven't worked and the fact that we got them in front of members at a great value put that in people's minds that we are a destination for those things and so as we go forward, we'll just try and take those lessons and apply them judiciously and our whole aim as a team is about how can we invest in the member and so We'll continue to do that again within the construct of the economy and our own P&L.
Edward Kelly
Analyst, Wells Fargo
The flip side of all this investment and a strong return on that is how do we think about 2027 and lapping a lot of this? I don't envy you in terms of how you think about guidance for next year. and I know it's early, but any thoughts on, you know, what does the real base year sort of look like in 26 as we think about, you know, like an algo or growth number for 27? Any early thoughts around that?
Bob Eddy
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
Yeah. You know, we kind of knew this question was coming. We had bets on how many questions we'd get to celebrate good results before we get into what happens next year. And so we're happy. This is a little bit of a champagne problem for us. We'll be coming off the best year we've ever had as a company this year off of the best one we've ever had last year and the year before that. And so I dare say we won't have another once-in-a-career legal settlement. So it'll be tough to have another quarter as profitable as this one in that regard. will obviously not, you know, anniversary of the $150-odd million of spending we did in a quarter either. And, you know, that leaves aside the other benefits we've had this year, tariff refunds and excess gas income and the like. But that only contemplates the benefits that we've seen. We've also had some bad guys we haven't expected, like $6 diesel and increasing medical costs and, you know, and the unplanned investments in member value that we used tariff-free funds to fund. And we took some of the fair winds and gasoline that we saw in Q2 and invested that as well. And so, look, I think it's tough to give guidance at this point. We're obviously not going to do that. And each year in the recent past, at least since COVID, has been very dynamic and had good guys, probably more good guys and more bad guys than anybody has anticipated. So I've kind of stopped trying to anticipate what's going to happen every year. And rather we just take what comes at us and try to make the best decisions that we can on behalf of our members. And again, within the construct of the economy and our P&L. So As we always do, we'll work hard to mitigate any of the bad guys that come along, and we'll invest any winnings on behalf of our members, too.
Edward Kelly
Analyst, Wells Fargo
Thanks, guys.
Conference Operator
Operator
Your next question comes from the line of Simeon Gutman from Morgan Stanley. Please go ahead.
Simeon Gutman
Analyst, Morgan Stanley
Hi, everyone. Thanks. Can you hear me? Yeah. Hi, Simeon. Okay. Hey, good morning. Hey, so first question, this powerful impact that you've had on comp and MFI from maybe the 42nd birthday and other things. Can you talk about how well split the impact is across your footprint? Was it highest or the strongest in some of your highest market share markets? And I know you didn't speak to it directly, but have you seen more frequency since?
Bob Eddy
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
I don't know that there's really been any difference in terms of the impact of the promotions that we did from a geographic perspective. We saw terrific results across our chain in existing clubs, I mean, legacy clubs and new clubs in super strong markets like New England and Florida or New York versus less dense markets, I think. We put such good promotions out there and such good items, such relevant items out there that no matter where the members were, they reacted to them. And so that was terrific. We really were proud of that. We weren't trying to target anything.
Bill Werner
Chief Development Officer
We were trying to target every member and give them something to feel great about.
Bob Eddy
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
And I feel like we achieved that goal. From a frequency perspective, it's a little early in Q4 to comment on anything, but I would imagine based on what we saw in Q3 that that will help frequency in Q4 and beyond. We're pretty proud of what we accomplished in the third quarter and hope that will benefit us in the future.
Simeon Gutman
Analyst, Morgan Stanley
Okay. My follow-up, and if you were betting on how many of these basic questions you were going to get, I'm going to give you another one, just basically the same thing. Thinking about you have this financial impact, and Bob, you've worn different hats, both financial and now full strategic and operational. I guess Wall Street's worried about what went into the mix this year, both from a financial perspective, and now from a customer perspective. Customer, you have this lever in membership, which is unique, so an ability to retain the business that happened this year. And by the way, every retailer this week, we're contemplating what the base is. And I think the operators don't sound that worried the way that you described it because you have offsets. I guess, is that the right way to look at it? You'll be able to lap it. Like you said, you'll be able to take other areas of expense out of the business. You're lapping gasoline. but there are some pretty big financial impacts that I think Wall Street is concerned about that operators are not as. So any more flavor to what you just spoke to would be helpful.
Bob Eddy
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
Yeah, look, I think it's going to be difficult for me to take every good guy and bad guy and sort of tell you how we'll mitigate those or deal with those. because I don't know what's going to happen in the future from a good guy, bad guy perspective, right? So very simply, you know, again, I feel like I'm repeating the last answer. We're not going to anniversary the settlement and we're probably not going to anniversary all the investment we did in Q3. So that's easy to think about. But what happens from a diesel perspective? Not sure. What happens from a medical cost perspective? Not sure. What happens from a gasoline income perspective? Not sure. and so it's very hard to answer that. I can tell you we understand our commitment to our members to offer them great value and so we will put that first and foremost and we understand our commitment to ourselves and our shareholders as well and so we will do our best to really find that base and improve against it and I think the team understands the The assignment for next year, I think we have some irons in the fire on how we will lap the stuff that is lappable. But again, we kind of don't know what's coming. And I do think there will be considerable pressure coming from a price increase perspective out there, if you take just one thing and talk about the diesel cost. Certainly, that is real. Every one of our competitors is experiencing that. We're experiencing that. We've We've offset that in our P&L with tariff refunds in some ways, for instance, or with gasoline income. I think that could be a headwind next year. It could be offset by raising prices. It could go back down to $4 a gallon, and then it's not a problem. Again, I think we'll just take what comes at us and manage within the scope of what we can manage. We can't control everything, but we will control what we can control.
Simeon Gutman
Analyst, Morgan Stanley
Thanks for the answer. Good luck.
Conference Operator
Operator
Thanks. Your next question comes from the line of Chuck Grom from Gordon Haskett. Please go ahead.
Chuck Grom
Analyst, Gordon Haskett
Hey, good morning, everybody. Just now, this image question, you talked about the potential for an uptick in frequency here in the fourth quarter, and I guess maybe into 2027 from your actions that you took in the third quarter. So I guess The question is that typically what you've seen, and I guess the million dollar question, Bob, is there a way to quantify how much of a comp bump you saw in the third quarter from the 42nd event? And then, Laura, maybe you could speak to the actual traffic increase in the third quarter. Thank you.
Bob Eddy
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
Yeah, sure. Thank you. We talked about the 42nd birthday promos driving about a point of comp. It's a little bit of a messy math exercise to figure that out. It's obviously impacted by the dollar impact of those promotions. It's probably not the best way to judge the performance of those promotions either, the units and the traffic being being up nine and six are better indications of how powerful those promotions were. I said in the prepared remarks, we haven't seen traffic increases like that since COVID, right? To have that traffic over six weeks for us was very, very cool and very, very hard for our operations team to deal with and our supply chain team to deal with. But talk about champagne problems. We're thrilled to see that, and we know that that comes back to us in the future simply through membership renewals. There's a linear impact between trips and renewal rate, and we're already seeing a renewal rate ticking up as a result of that, which means more trips in the future. I'm not going to give you a detailed answer to your question because we're not giving guidance for next year, but we do know that. We should have a pickup in Q4 and in next year because of it.
Laura Felice
Chief Financial Officer
Yeah, and then, Chuck, maybe I'll jump in on specifics on your traffic question. I think there's two important things I'd point you to. The comp traffic during the promotion, which Bob already talked about, the plus 6%, which is incredible. Our members were showing up. They saw the value. They rewarded us with trips and basket. And then for the full quarter, not just the promotion, our comp was largely driven by traffic this quarter. And so you've heard us talk about it's either been a balance between traffic and basket as we progress through the year. This quarter, it was more traffic driven. We like that behavior. Again, hanging on everything Bob said earlier and we said in the prepared remarks, traffic drives the membership flywheel. Our members are seeing the value that we're offering, whether it's assortment or pricing or convenience with things like express pay, and all of those should augur towards lifetime value benefit in the long term and our members continuing to reward us.
Bob Eddy
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
Maybe I'll just add on one thought. We planned to exit this year from an MFI perspective around 6%, and we just told you today we're going to leave this year around 7.5%. That's the result of signing up more members and engaging them. That's probably the best number we've had, X fee increase, as a company in a while. And so We had a terrific quarter within membership. Team's done a fantastic job. We talked about the 200,000 members in a month. We'll hit 9 million members during Q4. There's all these things that we can talk about, but that simple change of run rate in MFI is a product of what we did in Q3.
Chuck Grom
Analyst, Gordon Haskett
There's no doubt about that. My thought is just on the skew rat a little bit. In the past, we've talked about some spotty history, and I know you don't want to go down that road again. So I guess what have you learned so far in wave one? It doesn't sound like you've alienated any of your customers, but how are we thinking about the progression into next year? You talk about it being a two-year process. Is there any reason why you couldn't accelerate that? So just any initial observations. Thank you.
Bob Eddy
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
Well, you sound like me when I'm in these meetings. I wanted to go faster because I know it's important and I know it's working. In the past, we simply deleted repetitive SKUs and we didn't really change space allocation. We didn't add other categories or items that are more relevant and growthy. And that is what we're doing now. So when we talk about a SKU reduction amount of 20%, and so we have wave one on the floor now in our grocery business and we're seeing fantastic results from it. We haven't alienated members, we haven't lost sales dollars and we're importantly getting people to buy these better, growthier products from us and then we're experiencing the the ancillary benefit of having a simpler assortment for our operators and our logisticians to figure out. And so, look, we're super early in this. We've only got the first one on the floor. The second one will come in Q1. The third one will come in Q2 next year. It does take a while to figure out what we want to put on the floor, negotiate it all with our suppliers, get all the product, and make sure we roll it out effectively to our members. We're going to go as fast as we can We can go. Our merchants are excited about it based on what we've seen so far in the first wave. And more importantly, our members are excited about it. And look, we're just getting started. Our merchandising team is doing a fantastic job on this. And hopefully, as we go forward, we'll just see that impact built.
Chuck Grom
Analyst, Gordon Haskett
Great. Thank you. Thanks, Chuck.
Conference Operator
Operator
Your final question comes from the line of Michael Baker from D.A. Davidson. Please go ahead.
Michael Baker
Analyst, D.A. Davidson
All right. Thanks. Great. I'll ask two quick ones here to end. So what's the usual renewal rate of the discounted memberships that you offered during the event? In other words, that 200,000 new signups, do those usually renew around 90% or something different? And then I'll ask my second question. I wonder if you had a bet on how long it took for someone to ask this one, but... as I look out my window, it's 65 degrees in Boston. You can't be selling a lot of fall apparel. It seems like your guidance is looking for two to three or so in the fourth quarter on comps, but if you could maybe talk about what you're seeing in terms of the weather. A lot of retailers have talked about it starting off slow because of the weather.
Bob Eddy
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
Thanks. Good morning. So listen, we've talked about this in the past. Discounted memberships come with with Easy Renewal. Those folks have to renew. With that said, they're first-year members, and so they don't renew it 100%. They renew it something less than that. But it's our job once we get them to sign up in that first year to engage them. And that was one of the cooler benefits of the stuff we did in the third quarter. And we haven't quite unbundled all the lessons from it as we look at the analytics, but One of the things that we and I know our competitors have been fighting is more and more members come in to our franchise through digital meets and they don't just show up in our physical stores and make their first purchase on the day in which they sign up for our membership. And there's a really tight link between when they sign up and when they shop as you think about the quality of their membership. And and so we've all been sort of fighting how do we engage these people that show up digitally they'll show up on a website or an app or whatever sign up for a membership and then they don't make a purchase for a month and that is a markedly different member than somebody who signs up and purchases on the same day and pairing up these membership offers that we did in Q3 and the 42nd birthday party that gave people a tremendous range of promotions to react to at the same time they were They were signing up for membership and arguably probably drove many of them to sign up for membership. It really changes that dynamic in terms of the quality of the members that we get out of any particular promotion. We're excited to get the read on the numbers on what did that better engagement model look like from a quality of membership perspective. I anticipate that it will look much better. I anticipate the renewal rate of these members will be better, but we haven't seen the read yet. It's just far too early. And look, as we think about the weather, it's certainly been favorable in Boston. We operate in 22 states now, so it's not quite just a Boston story. It's been a very nice fall here, and I think That probably has driven a little bit of a slower start to winter apparel. But go back to what we talked about in the 42nd birthday with 500,000 pieces of outerwear. That's all winter apparel, right? So we really, I think, have done a fine job from an apparel sales perspective thus far. And we'll continue to try and put compelling products at great values in front of our members when the markets turn gold.
Michael Baker
Analyst, D.A. Davidson
Fair enough. Appreciate it. Thank you.
Conference Operator
Operator
This concludes. Sorry, go ahead.
Bob Eddy
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer
No, I just said thanks for every participation. Appreciate your support.
Conference Operator
Operator
This concludes our Q&A session. Thank you all for attending today's call. You may now disconnect.